A plan to correct a decades-old mistake in South Lake Tahoe’s official seal has ignited strong emotions among residents and local officials. The controversy centers on an inaccurate depiction of the Lake Tahoe border that has existed since the city’s founding in 1965.
When the city was incorporated, its seal mistakenly represented the geographic border of Lake Tahoe. This error, unnoticed for nearly sixty years, has now become a focus of civic debate as the city council considers whether to fix it.
“The city seal has stood as the link between our past and present. It has marked every chapter of our city's history, and remains a powerful emblem of who we are,”
said City Clerk Susan Blankenship, holding back tears while defending the original design during Tuesday’s council meeting.
“We’re just going to fix an error that went overlooked for the last 60 years,”
countered Councilmember Scott Robbins, who viewed the correction as a straightforward administrative update rather than an emotional issue.
Not all locals agreed with the need for change, expressing frustration over the debate itself.
“When I go to the store, the bar, the restaurant, anywhere — the hospital — I haven’t heard one person say, ‘We need to change the damn seal,’”
said resident Scott Loberg, emphasizing that most citizens didn’t see the alteration as necessary.
The city council will revisit the proposal for possible approval at its next meeting on November 18. The current seal remains distinct from the city logo, which can be modified independently at any time.
The long-debated correction of South Lake Tahoe’s city seal has revealed deep emotional ties and community divisions over preserving history versus fixing a decades-old error.