‘All’s Fair’ Review: Kim Kardashian Leads Ryan Murphy’s Hollow Hulu Drama
Naomi Watts, Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, Teyana Taylor, and Niecy Nash-Betts star in a series centered on an all-female divorce law firm representing exclusively female clients.
Kim Kardashian might be the ideal choice as the lead of All’s Fair, Ryan Murphy’s sleek new legal drama on Hulu. This is not because her acting shines—quite the opposite. Surrounded by powerhouse performers like Glenn Close and Naomi Watts, Kardashian’s wooden and emotionless performance stands out more starkly.
Her lack of authenticity matches the show’s writing, which is equally stiff and devoid of genuine emotion. Kardashian’s presence seems designed to generate buzz rather than engage viewers, aligning with a show that feels crafted more for viral moments than for consistent storytelling.
The other actresses struggle to bring life to material unworthy of their talents. The series constantly reminds viewers of the luxury and wealth of its characters, which detracts from any deeper connection.
“For their sakes but also for my own ability to believe in a world that occasionally makes sense, I hope that all of them, Kardashian included, collected huge paychecks for whatever they’re doing here.”
Summary: The series features strong talent overshadowed by weak writing and a lead whose wooden performance fits a show seemingly made for buzz over substance.